Sunday, April 8, 2012

Good Friday Road Race 2012

The one thing I was leery about going into this race was getting involved in a crash. There had been a lot of chatter on the Canadian Cyclist Forum about the likelihood of a high turnout for this race and the fact that, due to the nice weather we'd had, that many people would have better cycling fitness than usual for this time of year. The worry was that, with the yellow line rule (riders are not permitted to cross the yellow line under any circumstances. Where there is no yellow line, riders must stay on their own half of the road), and field sizes of 100 or more, the race(s) could become dangerous as riders jockey for position, the danger being with this being the first race of the season that participants could be a little out of practice with the intricacies of riding at speed in large packs.

Larry Bradley, Phil Hodgkinson, and I would be racing in the same M3 category so we had discussed ahead of time the importance of lining up close to the start-finish line for the start of the race. After a rather brisk warmup, Jon and I made our way to the start-finish line where we met up with Phil. The Elite 4 category, which was Jon's group, were to start 5 minutes after the M3 category so Jon went back behind the M3 group to line up there. Phil and I took up positions behind a row of CHCH riders who looked to be dominating the front of the grid. I looked around for Larry but he was nowhere to be seen.

Larry lining up for the start of the M3 race.
As we waited for the start of the race, I went over all the instructions Stan had told me: stay on the side opposite the wind and "hide" as much as possible, conserve your energy, stay in the top 10-20 riders in order to "stay out of trouble". Eventually, the gun went off and we were underway. Since the wind was coming from the North, the correct strategy entailed riding close to the yellow line heading West and North but staying close to the shoulder heading East and South. The course was one big rectangle so it would be hard to mix this up.

Given the large contingent of CHCH club riders across the front of the start line, I expected them to control the start of the race but as we quickly got up to speed I found myself stuck behind one CHCH rider who seemed to be quickly slipping backwards. Because I was behind him, this meant that I too quickly slipped backwards through the field. Up ahead, Phil seemed to be having no difficulty staying near the front. It was surprisingly difficult to interject myself into the stream of riders to my left but I was eventually able to do so and soon passed the slower rider in front of me and was able to move up towards where Phil was.

About halfway along the Northbound edge of the course, there is a short but somewhat steep hill. The pace up to this point had been fairly pedestrian so I expected something to happen as we approached the hill. People around me seemed to shift into the small chain ring but otherwise we traversed the hill uneventfully. This small hill is immediately followed by a downhill and then a gentle ride towards 6th concession. The course gets steeper and more difficult once the right turn onto 6th concession is made. I stayed close to the front over this section of the course, close to Phil's wheel, half waiting for someone to attack.

The attack never came. Someone did move up on my left as we made this climb. It turned out to be Larry. As we turned East on 6th concession, I moved over towards the shoulder in order to "hide" from the wind as much as possible. Larry moved up towards the front and was soon leading the peleton. It's funny how "pack mentality" works but once Larry moved to the front, and with Phil and I both in the top 10, I suddenly found myself at the front behind Larry. It was as if the peleton was relegating control of the race to the three of us by right of us having three riders near the front. In retrospect, I think it might not have been a bad idea for the 3 of us to take control of the race but heeding Stan's instructions I dropped back a little and let others pass in front of me. To do so, I actually had to let a bit of a gap open up between me and Larry. Larry continued to pull the peleton for the rest of the lap; it wasn't until we made the turn onto 5th concession towards the start-finish line that other riders came around him.

Me and Phil staying close to the pointy end of the peleton.


In fact, one rider went around Larry quite aggressively and, thinking this was an attack, I jumped, quickly bridged up to the rider who had opened up a gap. I went around the break away rider, to let him know I was there, took a short pull and then flicked my elbow to signal him to come around. When nothing happened, I took a quick look behind me and saw that there were three of us and we had a bit of a gap to the peleton but nobody seemed willing to work to stay away and we were soon all together again.

Once the peleton regrouped, the pace slowed once again. I began to get frustrated. This was not feeling like a race at all. But I took up my place on the leeward side of the peleton and tried to remain patient. We turned North and the pointy end of the peleton were strung out along the yellow line but moving fairly slowly. With the right hand side of the lane fairly clear, other riders quickly moved up the right hand side and maneuvered their way ahead of me.Again I found myself slipping backwards through the field and in frustration I launched an attack up the right hand side of the road. After a couple of hundred metres, I looked back to see that nobody had followed me. Since it was inevitable that the peleton would reel me in, I sat up and waited for them to catch me back up. It didn't take long. Once I was caught, we resumed our agonizingly slow pace.

As we turned East onto the steepest part of the course, things seemed to pick up a little and I thought a couple of riders looked to be making a break but we were all brought back together in short order. In fact, shortly after descending the downhill along this stretch, the commissaire's car went by and put the brakes on our entire field in order to allow the Elite 4 group, who had started 5 minutes behind us, to pass. By the time the Elite 4 group passed by, we were close to Brock road where the course turns South. We made the turn and I dutifully moved towards the shoulder side of the road in order to "hide" from the wind.

Riding Southbound along the shoulder on Brock road, I again found myself slipping backwards through the field as other riders moved up the left side to take up positions ahead of me. Again I became frustrated that the riders ahead of me seemed content to allow this to happen and in frustration I moved onto the shoulder, passed the entire field and continued ahead in another solo attack on the peleton. A few hundred metres later I looked back to see I had opened up a pretty good gap but again nobody had come with me. A short while later I took another look to see that the peleton was reeling me in so again I sat up.

As we turned onto 5th concession once again, several riders appeared to attack but by now I realized they were just making it look good for the crowd of onlookers and these weren't "real" attacks. Once we passed the start-finish line, the slow pace resumed.

On the 3rd and final lap, I decided to try and attack on the gradual climb following the short hill. This section was into a headwind with a slight gradient so I though I might catch the peleton napping but, again, I was soon reeled in and back amongst the peleton.

Across 6th concession, I "sat in" and allowed myself to recover from my most recent "attack effort which, due to the hill involved, had taken my breath away somewhat. As we turned Southbound onto Brock road, the pace seemed to pick up a bit as people began to anticipate the sprint finish and began to jockey for position. Things began to get a little more hectic at this point and on a couple of occasions I felt someone lean against me for several seconds after getting too close. I wasn't too concerned. "Coach" had instructed us on how to handle this. I had my elbows out as Coach had instructed and for the most part the "touching" did not affect me.

It was about halfway along this edge of the course that the pace began to increase quite noticeably. The jockeying for position became more pronounced and I found myself needing to ride somewhat aggressively in order to maintain my position in the front 10. I'm a little unclear what happened next because I seem to have lost memory of a good chunk of it but something happened in front of me. What I do know is that the rider in front of me went down and I think I went over the top of him. The last thing I recall is some notion of going headlong over my handlebars. The next thing I remember was being loaded into an ambulance on a stretcher by paramedics with Jonathan at the rear door of the ambulance looking somewhat concerned.

On the drive to the hospital, the paramedics asked me several questions including what day it was. I was unable to tell them what day it was right way but I was able to correctly provide my home address. My stay in the hospital was short and sweet. I stayed long enough to get a Tetanus shot and a Cat Scan and was then permitted to leave. I still don't know whether or not I suffered a concussion but the scrambled state of my brain all weekend suggests that perhaps I did.

The road won!


So, first race done. Not exactly what I expected. I did everything I was supposed to do but still ended up on the pavement. Such is the nature of bike racing. Next race is Calabogie in 2 weeks. I'm looking forward to it.


Elite 4 Race:

3216374632WESTWOOD, JonKURZAWINSKI COACH/ PBNJ.CARMU23.41h 37' 22"11' 49"

 M3 Race:
926074360HODGKINSON, PhillKURZAWINSKI COACH/ PBNJ.CARMMB.31h 31' 52"
2225975252BRADLEY, LarryKURZAWINSKI COACH/ PBNJ.CARMMA.31h 31' 52"
DNF26174633WESTWOOD, RichardKURZAWINSKI COACH/ PBNJ.CARMMC.3DNF

Race finish - Phil came ninth.


Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Guest Blog - Exercise Away the Cancer Blues

Hi all!

I would like to present this guest blog from David Haas, an advocate for cancer patients.

=========================================================

Exercise Away the Cancer Blues

If you are someone who is in the middle of cancer treatment or you have just

recently finished your treatment, you’ll discover that exercise is one of the best
things that you can do for yourself. WebMD states that exercise will, among other
things, improve mood, reduce fatigue and boost your self-confidence. The truth
of the matter is that in many ways, exercise gives you more control over your
own body and a bigger way to take control over your own life. Consider how you
are moving towards your goals and consider what exercise can do to help.

When you are recovering from mesothelioma treatment, you are going to
discover that exercise might be the last thing on your mind. You have had to
deal with many different things in the previous few months, and you will discover
that with all of that going on, you might not be interested in stepping on the
treadmill or going to the gym. The key to this is going to be taking the time to
find an exercise that works for you. This might be a great time to try some kind
of exercise that you have never considered before. For example, consider how
you might enjoy the gentle nature of water aerobics or the simple relaxing fun of
yoga.

Take a moment to think about where you want to be when it comes to exercise.
If you have never exercised before, this is a wonderful time to start. Cancer takes
away a feeling of vital control over your body while exercise gives it back. While
you are dealing with cancer, you find that you are too tired or too worried to do
the things that you love. On the other hand, when you exercise, you are going to
discover that you get some of that old energy back, and on top of that, you get
the endorphins that are going to help you get where you want to go.

What kind of exercise suits you, and how can you find the right type? First, start
by talking with your doctor and learning more about the exercise that will best
suit you. This is something that can make a huge difference when you want to
move forward with your health and your fitness. Consider what your options are
going to be when you want to get in shape after a long time away from the gym.
Remember also that you can work on your fitness at home. Whether you want
a weight machine in your basement or you would like to designate one of your
spaces as a yoga and meditation spot, there are some fabulous choices for you.

Take advantage of the many options that interest you and start your post cancer
workout today!

by David Haas
http://www.blogger.com/profile/08616835462804462281

Monday, April 2, 2012

Post Analysis - Block #3

This blog analyzes my progress through the last of three 6-week Winter training blocks using the same fitness metrics used in blocks 1 and 2. I also evaluate how well I fared on my Winter training objectives. To be honest, I didn't really very motivated even to write this final blog in my Winter training series but for completeness, here it is.

Analysis

Chronic Training Load (CTL) represents a measure of training fitness or, in this case, Cycling fitness to be specific.

Figure #1: Increase in CTL (blue line) over the 6 week period comprising block #3.

Figure 1 shows that CTL during block #3 rose from 94.5 to 103.3, an increase of 8.8 Training Scress Score (TSS) points. As was the case in blocks 1 and 2, this is a rather modest increase compared to the 5 TSS per week increase that frequent posters of the Google Wattage group recommend for ramp rate. But, as discussed in my block #1 post mortem, I was already starting from a comparitively high CTL level so there really hasn't been a lot of head room for me to be able to sustain a high ramp rate. I did, however, have a higher increase in CTL block #3 over block #2 which was also higher than the increase in block #1. It should be noted that my CTL value as of the end of my Winter training period is still about 9 TSS points shy of my peak CTL value of 112 from last season.

Block initial FTP increase in CTL 
Block #1 260 3
Block #2 270 7.5
Block #3 275 8.8
Table 1: Increase in CTL (measured in terms of TSS points) in blocks 1 to 3.

Table 1 compares the increase in CTL over each of my three training blocks. It shows 3-point, 7.5 point, and 8.8 point increases in CTL for each of blocks #1, #2, and #3, respectively, indicating my increase in training load has been progressive. My Functional Threshold Power (FTP)  used to calculate those TSS points was also raised at the beginning of blocks #2 and #3 (see Table 1). Since FTP determines my training zones, an increase in FTP at the beginning of each block meant having to pedal harder in order to hit my zones. Indeed, I did find the start of blocks 2 and 3 to be hard. But by the end of each of these blocks, my body had adapted nicely to the increased workload.

Zone Block #1 Block #2 Block #3
Active Recovery 24.2 13.2 9.4
Endurance 49.7 39.3 40.8
Tempo 19.3 28.2 33.9
Threshold 4.2 14.9 14.0
VO2 Max 1.5 2.7 1.1
Anaerobic Capacity 1.1 1.7 0.8
Table 2: Percent time spent in each training zone for blocks 1, 2, and 3.

Table 2 shows my distribution of  effort across training zones for each training block. This shows a slight increase in percentage (5.7 %) spent at Tempo with a little less time spent in Active Recovery. Indeed, the focus of my hard training efforts during block #3 involved lengthening the duration of time spent in the Sweet Spot (high Tempo to low Threshold) and four weeks of this six-week block were very structured towards that end. However, this 3rd block was also interrupted with a two-week stint in Florida where my goal was to simply get a lot of time in the saddle - a training camp of sorts with also a chance to spend some time with my parents. I did manage to accumulate 1,059 km during those 2 weeks with the majority of those kilometers spent in the Endurance to Tempo range. So, in fact, the percent time spent at Threshold during the 4 weeks of structured training in Block #3 would be actually higher than is shown in Table 2.


Figure 2: Total TSS accumulated for each six-week training block.
Figure 2 shows the total TSS accumulated during each six-week training block. What you see is a progressive increase in the training load I was able to absorb from block #1 through to block #3. TSS for block #1 average around 650 TSS per week which or just under 100 TSS/day. In block #2, that increased to an average of 700 TSS per week or 100 TSS/day. Finally, in block #3 I averaged 750 TSS per week or just over 107 TSS/day.

Conclusions

At the start of my Winter training program, I laid out some goals. In particular, I aimed to increase my Functional Threshold Power (FTP) by 30 watts from an estimated 270 watts to 300 watts. I had also a secondary goal to reduce my weight by 5 kg from 75.5 kg to 70 kg. Some dietary objectives that I set for myself included:

  • no refined sugars except during training
  • no coffee except before a hard or long training session
  • reduced wheat intake except in the training window (3 hours before and 3 hours after a hard session)
  • 1 beer per week
  • no "instant" food - if I haven't prepared it then I can't eat it
  • more fruits and vegetables
So how did I fare against my goals? The answer to this question is that I didn't even come close. Though I didn't do a formal test of FTP at the end of block #3, I gave myself an estimate of 280 watts as my FTP based on the tests I had done at the end of block #2 and how I felt in general. Regarding my weight loss goal, I was sort of on track up until Christmas. I had dropped my weight to 74 kg which was a start. But I indulged in Christmas treats and lost focus of my weight goal. I told myself that I didn't really need to drop the weight during my Winter training period and that in fact I might be better served to keep the weight on as I worked on developing more power. But in retrospect, this was a self delusion. I ate more than I needed to (see excellent article by Chris Carmichael on this: Cyclists Eat Too Much ). As for my dietary objectives, they lasted a mere 2 weeks. some of them were clearly unrealistic.  For example, there was no valid reason for me to eliminate coffee and instant foods and to reduce wheat. This was more of a case of jumping on the gluten-sensitivity bandwagon; I'm fairly certain I don't have a gluten sensitivity. There could be a case for reducing refined sugars and pre-processed foods but eliminating them completely proved to be too time intensive to even attempt. I did make a half-hearted attempt at more fruits and vegetables but I could have done a better job of this. As for restricting myself to one beer a week well, given my love for beer, that objective was ludicrous.

What would I do different? I have to say, by the time I left for Florida, I was sick and tired of the trainer. The hours on the trainer required to keep my CTL rising were beginning to take their toll. So what I will likely do next year is to take it easier in the Fall and allow my CTL to drop to a more reasonable starting point and maybe not even begin to do any serious interval work until January. Eighteen weeks of trainer intervals was just too much.

I didn't achieve my Winter training goals, ok, but was my Winter training effective? I'm fairly certain it was. In fact, I feel I've never been stronger on the bike for this time of year and yet I feel I have lots of room to ge stronger as the year progresses. Time will tell whether that's true of not, My first race is this Friday.


Sunday, February 5, 2012

Post Analysis - Block #2

This blog analyzes my progress during the second of three 6-week Winter training blocks. The analysis looks at improvement in fitness metrics as was done following block #1.

The first metric examined is ChronicTraining Load (CTL). CTL is a weighted average one's daily training stress score (TSS) over the most recent 42 days. It is considered a measure of one's cumulative fitness; the higher the CTL, the fitter the athlete.

Figure 1: Increase in CTL (blue line) in the 6-week period comprising block #2.
Whereas the increase in CTL for block #1 was a modest 3 point increase in TSS, Figure 1 shows an increase for block #2 of 7.5 TSS over 6 weeks (blue line). While still a modest increase, this value is twice the increase of block #1. This gradual increase in CTL is by design as I've learned from experience that ramping up Training Stress too early can induce psychological burnout if not physical overtraining.

In block #1, most of my training was predominantly in Zone 2 (Endurance) or lower. In block #2, I upped the intensity of my quality workouts such that more time was spent in Zones 3 and 4.

Figure 2: Percent time spent in each zone for block #1 (top) and #2 (bottom).

Figure 2, above, shows the percent of time spent in each zone for each of block #1 (top) and #2 (bottom). The figure shows visually a shift in emphasis from zones 1 and 2 in block #1 to zones 3 and 4 in block #2. The table below shows the percentage spent in each zone for blocks 1 and 2, again showing a marked shift in emphasis from zones 1 and 2 to zones 3 and 4 during block #2. This shift in emphasis was accomplished by increasing the intensity of my one hard ride per week from high Tempo (zone 3) to Threshold (zone 4) and by increasing the intensity of my 2 medium rides from Endurance (zone 2) to sweet spot (zone 3/4).

Zone Block #1 Block #2
Active Recovery 24.2 13.2
Endurance 49.7 39.3
Tempo 19.3 28.2
Threshold 4.2 14.9
VO2 Max 1.5 2.7
Anaerobic Capacity 1.1 1.7
Table 1: Percent time spent in each training zone for blocks 1 and 2.


Figure 3, below, shows weekly TSS for block #2. As in block #1, weekly training load was fairly consistent with even an upward trend. The third and sixth weeks were recovery weeks. The weekly training load was slightly higher in block #2 than block #1 .

Figure 3: Weekly TSS for block #2.

At the end of block #1, I forecast solid gains for block #2. In fact, my test of FTP for this block produced an FTP estimate of 275, a modest 5 Watt increase in FTP. Also, the modest rise in CTL shown in Figure 1 suggests only marginal gains were made in block #2 in terms of absorbed training load. However, the composition of that training load reveals where my gains were made. Figure 1 plots the 10 best average Watt sessions for each of 20 (green dots), 60 (red dots), and 90 (blue dots) minute durations starting from the end of last season to the end of block #2. As you can see from the Figure, there are a small cluster of points towards the end of last season where my fitness from the previous season was still high and I was riding outside. But the majority of points cluster towards the end of block #2. This shows that while FTP and CTL may not have risen substantially, my capacity to sustain that power over longer durations, what Friel would term muscular endurance, has improved markedly.

Looking foward to block #3, my training plan calls for longer durations at Sweet Spot, and Threshold. Block #3 will also include a 2-week stint in Florida where I hope to get in some solid base mileage outdoors. This should provide a good boost to my base and prepare me well for the start of the outdoor training season which, the weather gods willing, should coincide with the end of block #3.

Sunday, January 1, 2012

Post Analysis - Block #1

"It's not about the bike". What Lance Armstrong meant was that, to get faster on the bike, one needs to work on the engine; a lighter, faster bike isn't going to do it for you. Actually, I could dispute this. My carbon Masi is probably about 5 kg lighter than my steel framed Bauer and I can average about 2 kph faster on a long ride for the same effort. That's pretty substantial. Nevertheless, to be competitive against your rivals, one must focus on building a stronger engine. Which is precisely the goal I set for myself this Winter.

There are many ways to skin the bike fitness cat. My preferred method is based on the axiom "what gets measured gets done". As such, I rely heavily on my power meter to measure bike performance and a software tool called Training Peaks WKO+ to analyze my performance data. In this blog, I use WKO+ to analyze progress over my first six-week training block. A secondary theme is to see how many quotes I can fit in.

A first principle in building fitness is "progressive overload", otherwise known as "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger". Apply a training stimulus in excess of what the body is used to and the body will overcompensate by getting stronger. In WKO+, training stimulus is expressed in terms of Training Stress Score (TSS). A one hour ride at Functional Threshold Power (FTP) gives a TSS score of 100. To get the same score at a more practical low to mid Endurance pace requires about 2 hours of saddle time. Progressive overload, in these terms, entails a daily TSS in excess of one's recent TSS average.
Figure 1: A plot of average TSS (blue line) against time (horizontal axis).

The blue line in the chart above shows average TSS plotted against time where TSS is averaged over the most recent 42 days with more recent days given more weight. What the line shows is that my Chronic Training Load (CTL) at the end of last season was around 112 TSS. Attempting to introduce progressive overload from such a high starting point is not very practical as it would require progressively greater training stimulus either in the form of more riding or higher intensity resulting in diminishing returns. For this reason, an "unloading" period is required to shed some of the cumulative training load from the previous season. Or, as former FMCT coach Rob McCue would say: "To get in shape, you have to get out of shape". My 3-week unload period enabled me to shed close to 30 TSS (from 112 down to 84) which translates to roughly half an hour less riding per day required to produce an overload. The shedding should have been even greater but I got restless towards the end of my unload period and started to ramp up my training ahead of schedule. In retrospect, I should have shown more patience and let my CTL drop even further; 84 TSS is still somewhat high as an off-season starting point.

The goal for block #1 was not so much to introduce progressive overload this early as to establish a solid base. This is reflected in the blue line of Figure 1 where CTL rises modestly from 84 to 92 TSS before dipping again to only 87 TSS by the end of my recovery week, a cumulative increase of only 3 TSS over 6 weeks. To ensure that my CTL didn't rise too quickly during this base period, most of my rides were in the Endurance range as shown in Figure 2 below.

Figure 2: Percent training time in each zone.
Figure 2 shows that 75% of my training was in Zone 2 (Endurance) or below with 20% in Zone 3 (Tempo) and only 5% in Zones 4 to 7. My training consisted primarily of one hard ride per week targeting high Tempo range with two rides per week at mid to high Endurance range and 3 or 4 mountain bike rides per week at no specified target. Since I didn't have power data for the mountain bike rides, I estimated TSS using perceived effort and/or heart rate (WKO+ can actually provide an estimate based on estimated intensity factor and duration of workout).

Another important principle in building fitness is "consistency" of training. Figure 3 below shows my weekly TSS for each week of the six-week block.

Figure 3: Weekly TSS for Block #1.
Figure 3 shows weekly TSS was fairly consistent at around 700 TSS per week with recovery weeks of around 540 and 490 TSS for weeks 3 and 6, respectively. I found a weekly TSS of 700 to be hard enough to provide a good training effect but manageable enough that I didn't feel burnt out at any time during the training block.

Despite a fairly flat CTL (training load), my FTP by the end of block #1 was at or close to what it was at the end of last season. This bodes well for future progress as that important measure of fitness was achieved with a lower overall training load, meaning I have some head room to grow. My goal for block #2 is to increase FTP with some targeted high tempo/low threshold efforts. So time spent on the bike will remain about the same but effort on key workouts will increase. I'm optimistic about realizing solid gains during this next period.


Friday, December 23, 2011

Determining FTP - Test # 2

Leo's trail.


The trail where I walk Leo is pretty easy to spot in daylight. Surprisingly, the trail is also not all that hard to spot in the dead of night. What helps to differentiate the trail at night are the different shades of grey that mark the trail from the rest of the ground. A similar analogy can be drawn in determining Functional Threshold Power (FTP).

A problem with using test results to determine FTP are the many variables that can affect the outcome. How "fresh" one is on the day of the test, how motivated, the test environment itself, whether it was done outside or on the trainer, whether there was adequate cooling, all affect the results of the test. Comparing test results is even more difficult when different test protocols are used across tests. So, even though two FTP tests may provide two distinct FTP estimations, sometimes recognition of different shades of grey is required to hone in on a realistic FTP value.

Case in point, here are the results from 2 tests of FTP:

Date5 min20 minFTP*
Nov 7, 2011309W269W255W
Dec 14-16, 2011320W287W276W
* estimated

The test results shown above suggest an increase in FTP of 21 Watts in six weeks. While good for the ego, common sense suggests such an increase seems somewhat optimistic. A more likely explanation is that the first and second tests under-estimated and over-estimated FTP, respectively.

There is good reason to think that Test #1 underestimated FTP. The test followed a protocol prescribed in Training and Racing With a Power Meter, shown in the table below:

warm up
5 min all-out
10 min RI
2x1 min all-out (5 min RI)
3x20 sec all-out (3 min RI)
10 min RI
20 min FTP test
cool down

As you can see from the workout above, by the time the 20 min test is done,  the legs have been considerably "softened". In addition, that test was my first effort on the Trainer since last spring; typically indoor power tends to be lower than outdoor power at least initially (see Alex Simmon's blog on this). In this light, common sense suggests this estimate of FTP (95% of 20 min power) was probably low. I'm guessing about 5 Watts low.

Conversely, there is good reason to think that Test #2 over-estimated FTP. This test used a different protocol from Test #1 requiring a 5 min and 20 min test done on separate days and using a Monod Critical Power calculator to estimate FTP. The Monod Critical Power uses two interval readings to extrapolate one's power curve and, according to Alex Simmons, is <snip> "essentially equivalent to FTP (or at least a very good estimate of FTP)" <snip>. A pre-condition for using the Monod Critical Power estimate is that the tested intervals measure one's "best effort" at that interval. For this reason, it is important to test them on separate days so that the first effort doesn't interfere with the second effort.

According to the Monod Critical Power formula, my 5 min and 20 min test results of 320 Watts and 287 Watts, respectively, yield a critical power of 276 Watts. However, the Monod Critical Power formula falls down if either of the tests fails to measure one's true potential at that interval. For example, plugging a lower 5 minute value into the formula actually increases critical power while using a higher 5 minute value lowers it. In my case, I suspect that my 5 minute test was on the low side. Most of my training sessions have been 25 minute intervals; my 5 minute power has been comparatively untrained. Also, my legs felt still somewhat fatigued from my Egg Nog Jog effort. In this light, I'm not convinced that the Monod Critical Power calculation is a good estimate of FTP in my case at this time. A more reasonable estimation of 270 Watts makes more sense.


Date5 min20 minFTP*
Nov 7, 2011309W269W260W
Dec 14-16, 2011320W287W270W
* revised estimate

Taken together, the revised estimates of FTP suggest an increase of 10 Watts over the six weeks; a much more reasonable increase. Both tests above provide ballpark estimates of FTP. But accounting for shades of grey such as discussed above provide more common-sense estimates.